American Idol favorites Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were eliminated from the singing competition on Monday, May 12. The two singer-songwriters went home after 19 million viewers cast their votes during the second night of Disney performances on ABC.

Getting a vote of confidence from an “American Idol” judge one week before the season finale is likely a dream come true for every “Idol” finalist. But during Monday night’s episode of the singing competition, contestant John Foster received something even more meaningful: a vote of confidence from judge and former “Idol” winner, Carrie Underwood.